formed on an embryo to see if it also carries a genetic abnormality. PGD testing allows one to see if the child could possibly have diseases which are frequently followed by the difficult decision of keeping the child or eliminating the embryo if they feel that the results are unfavourable. As of right now, one can select from a list of over 4,000 items that are genetic disorders, and screen the embryos for any kind of genetic disease and even select a gender for their child to have. They look at the actual chromosomes which are responsible for causing those diseases. As desirable as it sounds, this whole process is very controversial. Currently, 35 countries have banned PGD because they believe that they should let the medical community interfere in the genetic processes. So do they have a point? Or are they completely wrong?
Well let’s look at the positive aspects of this whole situation. Couples that come in to such a clinic may currently have a child with a disease, or they have a family history of a disease, and they're concerned about passing that on to the next generation. I would certainly go through with this process if I knew I could prevent my child from a lifetime of ridicule, inequality, and disappointment. You go to countries and you'll see babies with easily preventable genetic disorders- the same countries that have basically have banned PGD. But many argue that this is simply unnatural. It is wrong to select the traits of your children, no matter how well your intentions may be. Dr Leon Kass and the President’s Bioethics Council in the United States have argued:
“Human reproduction is a ‘gift’ and that any form of selection or manipulation turns the child into a ‘manufacture’ and thus impairs human flourishing.” (Kass, 1998, 2000, 2002; President’s Bioethics Council, 2002)
When one has a child, they should love them unconditionally, despite all of their flaws. PGD however, allows this to be impossible because one can just eliminate what they don’t like about this unborn child. The deselected embryos are even discarded! Think of all the lives that have been lost because of PGD. T
his loss of life is completely against my beliefs and I can assure you, more people feel the same as well. In addition, increasing the technology of PGD will lead us into a world in which children are valued more for their genotype than for their inherited characteristics. This will eventually create a world of designer children in which genetic engineering becomes regular. Why would anyone take a chance of having a diseased baby or a baby girl instead of their desired baby boy when they could go to a doctor like Dr. Steignburg and say: “Hey Doc, I don’t want my baby to have any diseases and I want them to have green eyes, brunette hair, a button nose, and it better be a girl. “ This my friends, can be very dangerous.
So do the countries that have banned PGD have a point? You be the judge.
Works Cited
Dayal, Molina B. "Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis: eMedicine Obstetrics and Gynecology." EMedicine - Medical Reference. 11 Nov. 2008. Web. 28 Nov. 2009.
O'Reily, Bill. "GENETIC ENGINEERING OF BABIES A POSSIBILITY? North America United States from AllBusiness.com." Business Resources, Advice and Forms for Large and Small Businesses. 2 Mar. 2009. Web. 28 Nov. 2009.
"What is PGD." Reproductive Genetics Institute: PGD Experts. Reproductive Genetics Insitute, 2009. Web. 28 Nov. 2009.


